Yesterday saw the kick off of a new term at Toronto city council. By almost any measure, all non-BradBradfordians in this city should be upbeat about the next four years. A progressive if skittish mayor handily re-elected for a second kick at the can, this time around for a full four years.
A good crop of largely left-leaning new faces and the removal of some rickety deadwood although not nearly enough of it for my liking (looking at you Etobicoke, Scarborough and pockets north of Eglinton). And no singularly disruptive voice spending the entirety of their time in office in self-declared opposition and mayoral campaign mode.
Yet, despite all that favourable headwind, optimism toward the near future seems muted, guarded. The prospect of progress, any sort of forward motion on the pressing files currently afflicting the city, homelessness, open and rampant drug use, over-policing and underperforming public transportation, traffic congestion, climate change, grotesque income inequality, this dispiriting and disquieting municipal To Do list feels, at least from the outside, daunting.
Of course, that could just be a sign of the times, our Age of Fret. We’ve been living under storm clouds for so long, the grey hue does not easily lift. Even good news offers up few silver linings. Although, the foul stench wafting up from the south has dissipated somewhat with the blue wave of the U.S. midterms dampening the authoritarian spirit of Project MAGA. In fact, there’s been positive democratic signs globally in recent weeks. Brazil. Serbia. Before that Hungary.
And now, arguably, Toronto has the most left leaning council it has seen since the Miller years.
So,
Yay! us, right?
Full steam ahead! Let’s go full-on Mamdani! All in Nithya Raman!
Not so fast.
This is Ontario after all. That sour, subdued note hanging in the air? The actual mayor of Toronto, the mayor of Ontario, in fact. The part-time occupant of Queen’s Park, Premier Doug Ford.
Reason number one why we can’t have nice things, can’t fix the things that are broken, must content ourselves with simply nibbling at the edges and dare not to dream big. We can’t afford to upset the big guy or catch his attention in the least because he then tends to meddle, to get all up in our business, to fuck shit up simply because he can. It is his constitutional right, we’re told constantly by the courts, to inflict whatever damage he sees fit to inflict on this city out of pure spite, greed and malevolence. Good governance giving way to personal pique and retribution.
Nothing puts this dynamic more on display than a stroll, jog or cycle along the city’s western waterfront from, say, Strachan to Jameson or so, the entirety south of Exhibition Place. A scene of utter destruction made even more glaringly apparent with the lonely survival of the RBC concert stage and the Cinesphere ball, a sad reminder of a more thoughtful and collaborative provincial government from the days or yore. All in the service of a corrupt and woefully corporate vision of a premier looking to build a lakeside monument to his grafty tenure, a monument that, in this guy’s opinion, will never be built. At least, never built in its present brochure form.
The Ford Gash.
Which pretty much sums up his time as premier.
And all the province’s municipalities and regions can do is to look on and try as mightly as they can to minimize the damage.
Don’t get me wrong here.
Rarely has Toronto city council represented the city’s best and brightest or been on the vanguard of change, progressive adaptation and growth. Not since amalgamation, anyway, another body blow inflicted by another misguided and willful conservative premier. Certainly not since the appearance of Doug Ford on the political scene in 2010, riding his brother’s coattails into elected office the first time, already talking ferris wheels and shopping malls down by the water’s edge. There have been plenty of self-inflicted mistakes and own goals. Setbacks not of the premier’s doing to be sure.
But the city has been reeling since Ford’s elevation to premier in 2018, whether it’s been the cutting of council size in the middle of a municipal election, outlawing of ranked ballot voting, the aforementioned razing of Ontario Place, the utterly unjustified closing of the Ontario Science Centre, the ripping up of bike lanes.
Etc. & etc.
A collective flinch every time the man stands behind a podium at a microphone to make his latest announcement or on the precious few times he shows up at Queen’s Park to flap his gums. What the fuck is he up to now? we wonder. What’s next?
The good news is, his shtick is starting to wear thin even outside of Toronto. His government’s looking long in the tooth, as entropy tends to have that effect on all long serving governments. Insiders are speaking out against similar carnivalesque plans the premier has for Niagara Falls that he envisions for Toronto’s waterfront. “Dumb”, it’s been anonymously labeled. His undemocratic appointment of regional chairs after last month’s municipal election is raising hackles. His government’s hijacking of school boards. A proposed new law removing elected officials from public utility boards like Toronto Hydro. The ban on speed cameras.
Essentially, the undermining of local democracy province wide.
Which may provide a way forward for Mayor Chow and Toronto city council as it heads into its new term. Start pushing back. There are no more deals to be made with Doug Ford. The uploading of the Gardiner and DVP to the province in return for keeping mum on the ransacking of Ontario Place appears to be a one-time deal only, leaving an opening budget hole of $1.1 million for the upcoming fiscal year with no further help coming from Queen’s Park. Being conciliatory is a mug’s game at this point. Start poking back. Stop making it easy for Ford to run rampant through the city. Municipal tools are limited but use the ones at our disposal. Make the inevitable defeats loud and messy. Make Toronto’s fights against the Ford government every other provincial municipality and region’s fight as well. It isn’t just Ford versus Toronto. It’s Ford versus Ontario.
I know this approach goes against the grain of how Olivia Chow operates. The consensus builder. The facilitator of mutually satisfactory agreements. An approach that earned her a 2nd term, a 2nd term under duress. But now it’s time to cement her legacy. There’s no way to build a more vibrant, equitable, liveable city under the baleful watch of Doug Ford. That’s not just a Toronto reality. It’s a Niagara Falls reality. It’s a Muskoka reality. It’s a Mississauga reality. It’s a reality living life in Doug Ford’s Ontario.
Instead of seeking to constantly grease the wheels of give-and-take of negotiations, it’s time to sand the gears. It’s time to stand up to the bully. To make him wear the mess of his mistakes and missteps. Peaceful co-existence with Doug Ford is no longer a workable option.
Folks, when you're putting in full days as a bad premier, and then working overtime as the worst mayor Toronto ever had, you don't have time to learn a second language.