For three years now, ever since then-councillor Rob Ford announced his run for mayor, we’ve been clubbed over the head with the urban-suburban divide. The narrative of downtown elites hoarding all the goodness that is living in Toronto, leaving their suburban counterparts with nothing more than the crumbs and scraps. Get out of your cars so we can have bike lanes! No subways for you! Your taxes spent on us.
Rob Ford rode such resentment into office, and the continued suburban support maintains his not impossible chances for re-election next year. He is the self-proclaimed champion of the little guy in places like Scarborough, basing his entire transit policy around getting a new subway out there. Nobody rails about and profits from deriding the self-satisfied, special interest insularity of downtowners like the mayor and the rest of Team Ford.
An accusation I’ve tried to take to heart. Get out there, learn what makes these suburban types tick, their likes, dislikes, their pet peeves, their pet causes. Try and find out why they’re so mad at us and how politicians like Mayor Ford so easily tap into that vein of anger.
The latest leg of that journey outside of my south of Bloor/west of the Don Valley comfort zone took me to the Scarborough Civic Centre yesterday for their monthly Community Council meeting. Here you can see the local councillors and their constituents at work far from the spotlight of City Hall, not dwelling on the Us-versus-Them but instead focusing on pure Scarborough time (or North York or Etobicoke-York or Toronto-East York time depending on which community council meeting you’re attending). Community council concentrates on the minutiae of local governance.
As the agenda for the Scarborough meeting showed, this is the time spent adjudicating neighbours’ fence heights, debating the need for a stop sign or traffic lights, the removal of tree from private property, parking, always parking. It isn’t glorious or sexy. Just the nuts and bolts of the political process at the municipal level.
Perhaps the most charged item I witnessed yesterday was over the fate of the wading pool just outside of the civic centre. Apparently it was a community hub for the forty years of the building’s existence but last summer the This Is Not A Wading Pool sign went up due to the lack of funding to pay for a lifeguard. Scarborough councillors set out to try and rectify that situation.
Most of the time, big ticket, highly contentious, city wide items don’t dominate community council meetings. A casino, tall tower complex or the island airport runway expansion rarely find their way to be debated at North York or Scarborough community councils. The majority of those end up for discussion at Toronto-East York community council.
And Etobicoke-York, apparently.
For the last two months the west-end community council has had to conduct additional meeting time to deal with the public reaction to two developments that are being proposed in their catchment area. In April, there was an evening session at the Etobicoke Civic Centre over the proposed waterfront development in Ward 6, Mimico 20/20. And yesterday for six hours, the public came out to express their unanimous opposition to First Capital Realty’s intention to convert the Humbertown shopping plaza into a mixed up residential-commercial space.
This one was a biggie. As David Hains writes in the Grid, it was held in a 3,200 seat church on the Queensway, was broadcast on TV and streamed online and brought out much of the media as well as the big gun politicians like the mayor and his councillor-brother. (As a member of the Etobicoke-York community council, it’s not unusual that Councillor Ford was in attendance although, it is worth noting that he was absent for the Mimico meeting last month, choosing instead to attend a provincial Progressive Conservative fundraiser.)
Now, I don’t know if the Humbertown development is a good one or not. Certainly the community’s concerns over the increase in traffic caught my attention. It didn’t strike me as the disaster-in-waiting almost every speaker to person claimed it would turn out to be. There are voices living in the area that even think it’s a positive thing for the area.
What I will tell you, however, is that I didn’t care for the tone I heard from the development’s opponents. Like many who spoke out against the Mimico 20/20 plans, we were told the Humber Valley neighbourhood was like a village wrapped inside a big city. A place for families to thrive and grow, away from big city concerns. People were born in Humber Valley. They went to school in Humber Valley. They got married in Humber Valley. They have children of their own who they want to raise in the same Humber Valley they grew up in.
After a couple hours of this, I couldn’t help but think if these people really wanted the village life, they should maybe move to an actual village. Somewhere, I don’t know, in Amish country. Or maybe on the edge of the moors in south-west England. A village village.
Not a pretend one of their imagination, situated 1500 metres from a major east-west subway line. No, what these people want is to enjoy all the amenities a big city offers while keeping the messier aspects like intensification and underground parking (really, underground parking) at bay. This is a wealthy enclave with the time and resources which, as my friend Paisley Rae said, should not determine the outcome of the civic process, trying to keep the 21st-century from their front door.
And the real kicker is that these are our populist mayor and brother’s people not the poor schlubs having to endure a cold winters rid on the Scarborough SRT or even those living further north in Etobicoke, up in Rexdale. This development is right in both the Fords’ backyards and the little guys they’re looking out for are those who can afford to hire their own architect to draw up alternate plans and find the concept of shopping on a second floor inconceivable. I suppose you’re going to tell me that you’ve invented a moving staircase in which to ascend us to ladies wear.
“We cannot let these developers come in and bully us,” said the mayor who’s all in pushing a waterfront casino. He vowed to fight the Humbertown development ‘tooth and nail’. “Let’s go to the board (Ontario Municipal Board),” he urged if First Capital Realty didn’t back down, presumably with money from the city he often tries to stop at council when other communities faced with unwanted development face appeals at the OMB. Everything Mayor Ford purports to be got completely turned on its head with his strident opposition to the Humbertown development.
The fact is, Mayor Ford doesn’t really represent the aspirations or alienation of suburban Toronto. At least not those of the hard-working little guys in large portions of Scarborough or Etobicoke. It’s a very select few he will go to the mat for, the ones who essentially live in his own neighbourhood. The overwhelming majority of suburban residents are nothing more than votes to him.
— nimbly submitted by Cityslikr
The Mayor is against the creation of 237,000 square feet of retail and some 4 million dollars worth of improvements; paid for by the developer, to that Humber village paradise. I hope the OMB accepts the proposal sans sector 37 benefits and the developer doubles the size of the proposal.
It would appear that Rob Ford is the village idiot. He could use the help of someone like Adam Vaughan to negotiate development.
Here’s the Post article on Ford & Etobicoke
You don’t believe a community should be allowed to influence whatever is being decided for it? Citizens of Toronto should accept whatever a big property owner wants and is approved by Council?
Dear troll; It seems you & Simon do not see Ford’s hypocritical leadership. He’s placing his “Mayor Ford” magnets out where?
Sonny, its a business card, no a campaign sticker. And in the end who cares! Who cares! Who cares! You need to stop the incessant navel gazing.
As if the ‘johnny-come-lately’ folks at AFUITBS care! They spend 5 minutes observing the municipal system and spend the rest of their time pontificating. All of a sudden they’re experts on traffic and what it’s like to live in the Humber Valley neighbourhood. They have that,”we know what’s best for you” attitude that goes with being a downtown elitist. It’s not good enough to want to live your life in any way other than how they live.
It’s worse that they are wealthy enough to hire their own experts! That’s so unfair when so many others (too many?) have to live up in the sky overlooking subways, a harbour and an airport!
It’s a known fact, the local councillor trumps everything. Which means, if the local councillor is in the community’s corner, his or her position will prevail. There’s not much need for anything or anybody other than for a quorum. There’s hardly ever any need for deputants either, but we trot them out every time.
However, based on past experience, I’m suspicious. It’s well known that the local councillor calls the shots on planning. This project could be one that the local councillor pretends to disapprove of, but can’t risk a backlash at election-time. (Observe too, Ossington and Cllr Layton later this year)
Now we must pay for outside experts to challenge what we’ve already paid for from our own City Staff. The outside experts will have a hard time suggesting that the City is out-of-line rejecting this proposal when its own Staff have approved it. (Waste of money?)
That’s the real story here and one worth blogging about, if only the folks at AFUITBS had anything but hate for the Fords on their minds.
It’s another fact that Rob Ford has gone to the mat for communities to be heard all over Toronto. However, facts never stand in the way of a good hate, eh?
The best bit is the mayor’s quote re. Humbertown “we cannot let these developers come in and bully us”, which really smacks of hypocrisy, when he’s pushing for a casino and also an expansion of Billy Bishop against the will of many Toronto residents who don’t want these things.
Is AFUITBS pro-development or anti-development? It seems you flip-flop depending on what Mayor Ford supports.