The Long Shots — Challenger Endorsements III

Who doesn’t like a cinderella story? A rags-to-riches tale of unexpected triumph over seemingly insurmountable odds or an imposing adversary. The Little Engine That Could. Rocky. Those damn ants and that nasty assed rubber tree plantrubbertreeplant

We love them because such an arc is so exceedingly rare in real life. The best person doesn’t always win. Giving it your all won’t guarantee the podium.

Politics is no exception. Dark horses seldom catch anyone by surprise. Incumbency sits like dark matter, bending elections to its well. You don’t even have to be a very good incumbent. Most times, being an incumbent is all you need to remain in place.

Which is what makes people throwing their hats into the ring despite the improbable mountain they have to climb so absolutely edifying and inspiring. You got to believe in the rightness of your cause to face almost certain defeat and to forge ahead in spite of it. To dream the impossible dream, am I right?

So today, we’re talking long shots in our city council challenger endorsements. Three candidates who, on a level playing field, would be frontrunners based on their ideas, passion for their respective communities and dedication to civic engagement. Three candidates who have dropped the gauntlet on some less than impressive opponents and shown a willingness to fight an uphill battle for no other reason than it being a fight that needs to be fought.

 

endorsement2

Ward 34 Don Valley East

You’ve all heard this rant before. Long time incumbent Denzil Minnan-Wong serves in the upper echelon of divisiveness and destructiveness at City Hall. He seeks to shrink the efficacy of local government to little more than paver of roads and collector of garbage. He’s been doing that since the days before amalgamation.

His opponent this time around, Mary Hynes, is no stranger to City Hall herself but sits across the committee table from Minnan-Wong, speaking up for all the things he could care less about. He talks about taxpayers. She talks about community. We met and chatted with Mary in July, in the infancy of her campaign. She is well aware of the David versus Goliath aspect of this race but also knows in the past 3 campaigns, Minnan-Wong’s share of the popular vote has dropped.

Perhaps Ward 34 has just been waiting for the right alternative. Mary Hynes most certainly fits that bill.

We here at All Fired Up in the Big Smoke endorse Mary Hynes for city councillor in Ward 34 Don Valley East.

endorsement3

Ward 35 Scarborough Southwest

Paul Bocking is young, enthusiastic, articulate, with a fresh perspective about local representation. He projects a rosy-cheeked, can-do spirit that isn’t based on the fact he’s running against some entrenched, weezy, old guard councillor. He’s not. He’s running against entrenched, weezy, old guard ideas.

When we met this past summer, Bocking couldn’t stop talking ideas and issues. Almost all of them were in direct opposition to the incumbent he’s trying to unseat, Michelle Berardinetti. We’ve spoken often and never really very flatteringly about the councillor. Although just finishing up her first terms, it seems like she’s been there forever.

Scarborough is what Scarborough is because it continues to elect the likes of Michelle Berardinetti to represent its interests at City Hall. A little bit of Bocking could go a long way to changing perception and attitudes.

We here at All Fired Up in the Big Smoke endorse Paul Bocking for city councillor in Ward 35 Scarborough Southwest.

endorsement1

Ward 39 Scarborough-Agincourt

It’s hard to imagine worse representation at City Hall than outgoing councillor Mike Del Grande but I don’t think it’s out of line for me to say that the presumptive favourite in the race to replace him, Jim Karygiannis, doesn’t look to be much of an improvement. He retired from federal politics after 25 years in office and is looking to now bring the burning issues and values of 1988 to municipal politics. Exactly what Scarborough needs at this juncture.

The really frustrating thing is, it doesn’t have to be this way. Franco Ng, a former Del Grande staffer, would be the ideal way forward for the ward. He is obviously very familiar with the neighbourhoods and communities from his time at City Hall. His views on modernising the suburbs, revitalizing aging shopping malls and employment lands, are exciting. The afternoon I spent travelling around the ward with him in August was very instructive in how new voices can energize old ways of thinking.

Jim Karygiannis represents, if not a step back for Ward 39, a digging in of its heels or burying its head in the sand. It would be a waste of the next 4 years. Franco Ng would be a real opportunity to step into the 21st-century.

We here at All Fired Up in the Big Smoke endorse Franco Ng for city councillor in Ward 39 Scarborough-Agincourt.

high hopesly submitted by Cityslikr

Challengers To Watch XI

We’ve spent the last 4 years looking at costs and ignoring the benefits.

This is pointed out to me over dim sum by Franco Ng, city councillor candidate for Ward 39 Scarborough-Agincourt. ward39It’s a sentiment that comes as something of a relief to me because I had no idea what to except from somebody who’d worked in Mike Del Grande’s office for 4 years. Mike Del Grande, the penny-pinchingest, grumpiest and one of our least favourite city councillors.

Franco Ng is nothing at all like that.

This is not to say that during the two hours spent together, we agreed on everything. We certainly didn’t see eye-to-eye on LRTs in the suburbs (although Mr. Ng had no strong feelings about the Scarborough subway – he told me nobody was talking about it at the doors he’d knocked at either) or the right for permanent residents to vote but there was certainly a strong basis of understanding between us about what this city needs to do going forward in order to remain prosperous and a desirable place to live.

Franco Ng is what I’d call a post-amalgamation Torontonian. While having very strong ties to the ward, he’s been a north Scarborough resident for 15 years, there’s no sense of us-versus-them, suburb-versus-downtown, we get nothing-they get everything from him. bridlewoodmallHe wants to put Ward 39 on the map, make it a place people want to visit, move to, stay and raise families while working to make the city as a whole a truly global city. A place that isn’t just somewhere up there.

It will be a daunting task in many ways.

The ward is a typical single-use suburban ward, built around private vehicle use, now entering a phase where that’s no longer economically viable. I met Franco at the Bridlewood Mall, at the corner of Warden and Finch. Getting off the bus, I walked through a vacant part of the parking lot which was being used exclusively as a warming spot for seagulls. The mall had seen better days, for sure. Franco walked me through the inside, full of vacant stores. More modern malls, with better amenities were a drive away in nearby Ward 40 and up a bit in the city of Markham.

Plans were afoot for Bridlewood. Condominium developments were going up. There was a new library branch in the mall. Bright and busy for a Tuesday afternoon. You should see it during the school year or at night, Franco tells me. It already may be too small a space to accommodate the people who want to use it.bridlewoodmalllibrary

This was the kind of pressure places like Scarborough-Agincourt were facing these days. Competing with not only surrounding communities to attract residents, businesses, visitors, but the wider world around us. Huge tracks of land designated for heavy industry, much of which has departed to cheaper territories. What to do with it? The tension is playing out right now with the battle over building a TTC bus garage near a seniors’ residence that has encroached onto industrial land.

How can a local councillor deal with such macroeconomic and citywide issues?

Franco Ng proposes starting street by street, developing and promoting a pride in place in order to bring about better neighbourhood integration. He tells me there are few residents associations in the ward and no BIAs. None. Without those, there’s very little engagement within the ward or with the city as a whole.

This is a frequent point made by many of the council candidates I’ve met out in the inner suburban parts of the city. A noticeable lack of civic engagement. They are not participants in governance. bridlewoodmallcondoThey are spectators.

“There’s no sense of ownership,” Ng tells me. You don’t really know what you have until you take part in getting it, I guess. This is what happens when you treat residents as taxpayers and not hands-on contributors to the process of community building.

It’s unfortunate too because, despite my downtowner view of places like Ward 39 being car strewn hellscapes (I mean, there are a lot of cars, lots of wide, wide roads and parking lots, interminable bus rides to get places by public transit), there’s a lot of green, public spaces there. The ward has 16 parks, Ng informs me, with the jewel being L’Amoreaux. The hydro corridor is beginning to fill up with soccer leagues and the like.

The elements are in place to build on all that. It’s just going to take a new approach to local politics. Less insular and backward-looking and more embracing new possibilities.

It’s about seeing the residents of Ward 39 as resources not, well again, just taxpayers. Franco says that taxes aren’t really a hot topic with the residents he’s met. wardenbusPeople seem to get the difference between spending money and simply throwing money away.

When the Steeles-L’Amoreaux neighbourhood was ‘de-prioritized’ earlier this term and some of the services offered there scaled back, people wanted to know why. They get investment in the community, in people of the community. Taking us right back to the beginning of this. Costs versus benefits.

After 4 years of inflammatory, divisive in-fighting at City Hall, the easiest way to combat it going forward is to elect city councillors who aren’t entrenched in old approaches, old ways of thinking. Franco Ng has bigger fish to fry than simply nursing old grudges or championing empty political platitudes. He wants to kick start a real sense of community in Ward 39, put it on the map as somewhere people want to visit and move to. lamoreuxparkThere’s a whole new world of regional discourse and planning he wants to move on, a dynamic that’s very much in play for parts of Toronto where you simply cross a street to get to another municipality.

There are real choices and alternatives for voters in wards like Scarborough-Agincourt. Franco Ng is one of them. 2014 is shaping up to be an important race between the past and the future in Ward 39. Let’s hope (and work toward) it chooses to go forward.

encouragingly submitted by Cityslikr