Civic Cop Out

If there’s one thing growing as tiresome as the latest update of Mayor Ford’s scandals, sodoneit’s the cry for de-amalgamation from many of the mayor’s most vociferous critics. As if somehow having the mayor of Etobicoke allegedly smoking crack would make things alright in York, North York, East York, Scarborough and the old city of Toronto. None of us would have the taint of the hillbilly on us.

I know the de-amalgamation urge goes much further than that. Urbanism versus suburbanism. Reactionary versus progressive politics. Everything was just a-ok hunky dory in my neighbourhood until we had to join with Them.

But the things that plague us as a city, plague us all and were not confined to simply old political boundaries. The lack of proper transit building and other big ticket, aging infrastructure. Growing inequality. Our little civic cocoons were never as cozy and comfy as we may like to believe, back in the good ol’ days.goodolddays

Certainly there is some truth to this political divide we all are currently kvetching over; a divide expertly exploited by the Ford administration and its allies. But let’s not forget that for three straight elections, from 2000-2006, the amalgamated city settled fairly uniformly into a workable co-existence. This apparent divide we now face isn’t entrenched or unbridgeable. It’s simply a convenient narrative.

I found myself yesterday (thanks to Paisley Rae) up in the city’s northwest reaches in Rexdale. We wanted to take in the City Youth Council of Toronto’s Youth Consultation: Recreation and Youth Leadership Programs session at the Elmbank Community Centre. (For a thorough overview of the proceedings, #LetsTalkRecRexdale.)  We arrived early to wander around the area, get some sort of sense of a part of the city I’d never been to before.

Jesus Christ, people.

If we truly believe as a city that Diversity, Our Strength, then our clamoring for de-amalgamation is venal hypocrisy. diversityourstrengthIt’s just an empty motto, something we tout to prove our progressive cred. Watching the kids head home from Henry Carr or sitting having a coffee at the Albion Centre foodcourt and taking in the human flow, there’s our fucking diversity. And because we lost one election, we want to petulantly cut the already tenuous ties with parts of the city that didn’t vote in line with our expectations? We become not a city of neighbourhoods but enclaves.

People live in or come to cities because of the opportunities there. A place thrives through its ability to extend opportunities not restrict them depending on their area code. Let’s stop comforting ourselves with the notion that some politically manufactured ‘nation’ rejected our delicate sensibilities. Instead, let’s admit we failed to strengthen the connections between the various communities that make up this city.

It just so happens that I’ve taken in a number of public meetings over the last few months in Etobicoke. After last night’s, on the 40 minute bus ride back down to Kipling subway station, a thought struck me. angryvotersAt both the Humbertown and Mimico 20/20 sessions, where crowds gathered to have their say about proposed developments in their neighbourhoods, the overarching theme was they wanted to be left alone, they wanted no part of the direction Toronto was headed. Theirs were villages within the city. Exclusion rather than inclusion.

But last night, it was all about wanting in. To be a part of the city. To be included in the political discussions and decision making that was affecting the place they lived and worked. There was a fierce attachment to being from Rexdale but with the recognition Rexdale was a part of Toronto.

As we were leaving the meeting, a gentleman who was a teacher at a nearby school, said to us (and I’m paraphrasing here): lookinthemirrorThis is Rexdale. Not the shit (my word) we’re all reading about.

Not everyone wants to be a part of this experiment we call amalgamation. It is still a democracy. We can’t expect 100% buy in.

The fact is, Toronto is amalgamated, for better and worse, and not just by some provincial edict. It’s up to us to emphasize and work on the better and try to diminish the worst. There’s nothing to be gained in retiring to our own respective corners. Playing up the differences only benefits those looking to make their political fortunes.

angrily submitted by Cityslikr

8 Responses to Civic Cop Out

  1. Sonny says:

    Ford was fibbing when he said that TCHC has it’s house in order…
    I wonder what the young people in his hood have to look forward to

  2. Patrick Smyth says:

    Amalgamation has been the worst. We are governed by the worst – the hangers-on who managed to swim to City Hall. Katherine Wynne,and many others, saw that and fought against it. It started the divide and Councils since then have failed to govern fairly. Now, it’s up to Queen’s Park to reset – it controls Toronto anyway and I suspect it will reduce the number of clowns we’re paying for at City Hall. That wouldn’t be my ideal but there’s more to the mess than just Rob Ford. That kind of singular focus has been a big part of the problem with our civic discussion.

  3. I usually strongly agree with your writings. But to vehemently disagree with this.
    Amalgamation has been a disaster. This is because fundamentally, people from the inner burbs are different than people that live in the “old” Toronto. Their day to day lives are different. They want to live in a house with a yard and hate condos/”development”. They want peace and quiet..downtowners want hustle and bustle. They want to drive everywhere in their cars…downtowners loathe cars because they cost too much for parking and traffics is terrible.
    I’m not saying whose set of values are “better” or “worse”. They are just different, and they deserve to express their desires and like the way they want.
    When the rubber hits the road is how they want their tax dollars to be used. Transit, development, art, “city building” in general…these are not their priorities. They want to tax dollars to go towards making sure their neighborhoods are safe and clean..and that’s about it.
    And so, they elected a mayor that defends their wishes and obstructs any city building efforts. So the very thing you want to happen, bringing everyone in Toronto closer so we all share in the same services, is exactly what they don’t value. You can’t blame Rob Ford–he has a constituency that is fundamentally different than in the old Toronto.
    These are mixing apples and oranges into the same pie. Maybe the pie is sorta working, but honestly, apple pie and oranges are better on their own.

    • Sonny says:

      Peter; there WAS the “driver factor” in that Frod & Slitherman were running to eliminate the dreaded VRT. For 2013, there are now some 1 million cars vs the around 800,000 in 2010 which means more congestion & GHGs…Climate Change…Flooded DVP

      Etobicoke accounted for 13% of votes cast vs 25% Downtown, the rest is the big battle ground for the 2014 campaign.

      • Steve says:

        Your intentional slur of a person makes what you say mostly moot. An presents their dislike with a reason using adult language. Not childish temper tantrums.

    • Patrick Smyth says:

      Wow, the folks at AFUITBS are going to have a word with you. You’re supposed to like what they like, they’re not into differences. Wait ’til Sonny hears this too! He’s going to go ape-shit!

  4. When we were sitting in there, I realized – my desire for separation in the past was based on wanting a divorce from the poor leadership of the outer wards. I didn’t like the decisions these councillors make, the words they say or the votes the choose to make. I still don’t.

    But it’s not solved by throwing the baby out with the bathwater. Supporting people in engaging governance to make it work for them is better.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: