Maybe it’s the winter blahs. Maybe it’s the disappointment over the lack of an actual, real life snowstorm that failed to descend upon us last night. Maybe it’s just the lull before the budgetary storm, between the committee meetings and public deputations and flutter of indecision in the Ford administration about what and how deep to cut, and when the thing goes before the full council to be voted on in the last week of February…
I’m sorry. Where was I going with that? I’m a little distracted and been finding it difficult to concentrate on the goings-on around the city over the last few days. You see, there’s this little life-and-death struggle for democracy happening over there in Egypt, a country located smack dab between Syria and Iran if I’m to believe the good people over at Fox News.
It’s difficult, almost impossible actually, to summon up enthusiasm for the political battles here on the home front, whether its attacks on public transit or our libraries or public sector employees, not because they aren’t important to defend but right now they seem, not insignificant, just minor compared to what people are fighting for (and against) in Egypt.
I step out onto less parochial political terrain here very, very tentatively. My knowledge of Egypt specifically and the Mideast in general is nowhere near what it should be. Yet it does seem to be undeniable that what we’re witnessing there is a genuine democratic movement finally bucking up from under a horrifically repressive regime that has had the very explicit backing of western democracies for a very long time now.
This should be a cause for much rejoicing and enthusiastic support on our part, shouldn’t it? Cheers certainly went up when the Tunisian strongman, Zine El Abidine Ben Ali, was chased from the country he’d ruled for over 20 years last month. But in Egypt, well, things aren’t as simply clear-cut as all that.
The thing is, they never are. That’s just a fact of life. If choices were always easy, always starkly black and white, any knucklehead could make them. We probably wouldn’t even need to elect governments to do our thinking for us.
But when a people regardless of where they are, regardless of their religion, regardless of their… politics, let’s call it, coalesce under the banner of democracy to demand all those things we blithely take for granted like free speech, freedom of assembly, freedom from want, our first and only instinct should be nothing short of, absolutely. We are with you. What can we do to help?
The tepid responses so far from our governments, the western world, the developed democracies, to the situation in Egypt have been, while certainly not shocking or surprising, dispiriting and deflating. If we had reputations in the Arab world that could be damaged, it would also be damaging. Our humming and hawing while revolution and violent reaction rip through Egypt reveal, once more, that our commitment to democratic ideals are fickle and transparently arbitrary. No more so than when it comes to Muslim countries in the Mideast.
Every time we hesitate to embrace those in the region who put their lives on the line in the fight for a more fair, equitable and democratic society (usually in tandem with our refusal to jettison a relationship with a despotic autocrat who has helped maintain our ‘interests’ there with an iron fist), we cleave another wedge into the possibility of rapprochement with the wider society. We show ourselves to be hypocritical and undependable when defending the free wills of all people. Democracy is good. For some. It’s negotiable not essential for everyone. What’s in it for us, your democracy?
To deem a democratic movement inconvenient, inopportune or destabilizing suggests that there are certain conditions that have to be met before democracy can be granted which sort of undercuts every principle of democracy, doesn’t it? It’s as if the concept comes with an asterisk that takes you to pages and pages of fine print. Watching events in Egypt transpire in real time, it looks like one of those clauses reads: Some Muslims May Not Qualify.
Continued resistance to the Egyptians demanding justice and freedom suggests that we’re not, in fact, all that married to democracy. We’ve forgotten its true meaning and, ultimately, are no more deserving of it than those we’re watching die for it in Cairo’s Tahrir Square and throughout the country right now.
— submitted by Cityslikr
Maybe an International approach would be better! The problems with higher food prices & high unemployment made Mubarak intolerable so he should step down. (after 30 years you get stale) The people should decide who they want to represent them in the upcoming elections rather than the shams that happened under Mubarak…
When we write about local mandates; Miller got 57% & was moving on Transit in Toronto. Then Ford got 47% & has stopped the plans in favour of expanding a Sheppard Subway that is already underused! Most people voted for Ford to stop waste & save the VRT money. RF’s transit plan will waste money in broken contracts.
Sadly, the fine print seems to read No Muslims May Qualify. Dunno if we’ll ever see a fully independent democratic gov’t in the Arab world that makes the US, Canada, Europe, Israel happy. Democracy is preached but only if its to our liking…to wit, see the democratically elected gov’t in Gaza.
Dear penny; Mubarak said he will not be running again. I don’t think the people like the idea of his son who was being groomed as his successor…
Whatever emerges will be better because the young people want change(see internet shutdown)rather than one party rule. It will be interesting to see who the U$ & Israel support given the democratically elected Hamas example. It will be up to the people of Egypt to vote if they have the chance.
I was thinking about the Fox graphic; they have Iraq labelled as Egypt:which is in reality to the West…
Screw Egypt… We have REAL problems here… I had to wait 5 trains to get on at St. George Southbound this morning. It took so long, I had almost no time to grab my coffee before surfing the net at the office.
Not to mention all this snow…
Yes, we here at All Fired Up in the Big Smoke think Egyptians don’t yet fully understand that freedom isn’t easy. The trains don’t always run on time. The coffee’s not always hot. Internet connections are sometimes slow.